https://yaqeeninstitute.ca/_next/static/chunks/pages/about-us/our-…ment-to-scholarly-rigor-2181cf19792e352c.js

1!function(){try{var e="undefined"!=typeof window?window:"undefined"!=typeof global?global:"undefined"!=typeof self?self:{},t=(new e.Error).stack;t&&(e._sentryDebugIds=e._sentryDebugIds||{},e._sentryDebugIds[t]="287b6c6c-470f-49da-a3e0-c37831ed8355",e._sentryDebugIdIdentifier="sentry-dbid-287b6c6c-470f-49da-a3e0-c37831ed8355")}catch(e){}}(),(self.webpackChunk_N_E=self.webpackChunk_N_E||[]).push([[8057,9981],{8333:(e,t,r)=>{"use strict";r.d(t,{A:()=>l});var a=r(69174),i=r(37876);let s=[{title:"Our mission",href:"/about-us/our-mission",blurb:"What Yaqeen is and what it exists to do."},{title:"Our commitment to scholarly rigor",href:"/about-us/our-commitment-to-scholarly-rigor",blurb:"The editorial board, peer review, and how published work is updated or archived."},{title:"Ask Yaqeen",href:"/askyaqeen",blurb:"Direct answers about funding, fatwas, and how research topics are chosen."},{title:"Call for submissions",href:"/submit-your-paper-proposal",blurb:"How to propose a paper, and the standards a Yaqeen paper has to meet."}],l=e=>{let{currentPath:t,heading:r="More about Yaqeen"}=e,l=s.filter(e=>e.href!==t);return(0,i.jsxs)("section",{className:"mt-16","aria-label":r,children:[(0,i.jsxs)("div",{className:"sm:flex sm:items-center sm:gap-4 mb-8",children:[(0,i.jsx)(a.DZ,{level:2,weight:"font-semibold",color:"text-midnight",fontSize:"text-xl lg:text-3xl",className:"sm:whitespace-nowrap",children:r}),(0,i.jsx)("div",{className:"border-b border-orange-400 mt-3 sm:mt-0 sm:flex-1"})]}),(0,i.jsx)("div",{className:"grid md:grid-cols-3 gap-6",children:l.map(e=>(0,i.jsxs)(a.qh,{href:e.href,className:"rounded-lg border border-slate-200 p-6 hover:border-endeavour-500",children:[(0,i.jsx)(a.DZ,{level:3,fontSize:"text-lg",weight:"font-semibold",color:"text-endeavour-600",letterSpacing:"tracking-tight-1",className:"mb-2",children:`${e.title} →`}),(0,i.jsx)(a.EY,{as:"p",fontSize:"text-sm",color:"text-slate-700",lineHeight:"leading-relaxed",children:e.blurb})]},e.href))})]})}},48057:(e,t,r)=>{"use strict";r.d(t,{A:()=>f});var a=r(66284),i=r(14232),s=r(17638),l=r(97114),n=r(95311),o=r(69158),c=r(52916),d=r(91113),m=r(37876);function h(e,t){var r=Object.keys(e);if(Object.getOwnPropertySymbols){var a=Object.getOwnPropertySymbols(e);t&&(a=a.filter(function(t){return Object.getOwnPropertyDescriptor(e,t).enumerable})),r.push.apply(r,a)}return r}function u(e){for(var t=1;t<arguments.length;t++){var r=null!=arguments[t]?arguments[t]:{};t%2?h(Object(r),!0).forEach(function(t){(0,a.A)(e,t,r[t])}):Object.getOwnPropertyDescriptors?Object.defineProperties(e,Object.getOwnPropertyDescriptors(r)):h(Object(r)).forEach(function(t){Object.defineProperty(e,t,Object.getOwnPropertyDescriptor(r,t))})}return e}let f=e=>{let{title:t,children:r,isOpen:a,modalClassName:h}=e,f=(0,i.useRef)(),{overlayProps:p}=(0,n.e)(e,f),{modalProps:g}=(0,n.hS)(),{dialogProps:x}=(0,s.s)(e,f);return(0,m.jsx)(o.N,{initial:!1,children:a&&(0,m.jsx)(n.Sf,{children:(0,m.jsx)("div",{className:"modal fixed h-full w-full inset-0 bg-black/75 flex justify-center items-center",style:{zIndex:d.M.DIALOG_BACKDROP},children:(0,m.jsx)(c.m.div,{initial:{opacity:0,y:50,scale:.3},animate:{opacity:1,y:0,scale:1},exit:{opacity:0,scale:.5,transition:{duration:.2}},className:"relative",children:(0,m.jsx)("div",{className:"modal-container",children:(0,m.jsx)(l.n1,{contain:!0,restoreFocus:!0,children:(0,m.jsx)("div",u(u(u(u({},p),x),g),{},{ref:f,className:h,role:"dialog","aria-modal":"true","aria-labelledby":`modal-headline ${t}`,children:r}))})})})})})})}},86094:(e,t,r)=>{(window.__NEXT_P=window.__NEXT_P||[]).push(["/about-us/our-commitment-to-scholarly-rigor",function(){return r(99984)}])},99984:(e,t,r)=>{"use strict";r.r(t),r.d(t,{__N_SSG:()=>D,default:()=>z});var a=r(14232),i=r(54587),s=r.n(i),l=r(18125);let n=[{cmsSlug:"dr-osman-umarji",profilePath:"/team/osman-umarji",name:"Dr. Osman Umarji",title:"Director of Global Muslim Studies"},{cmsSlug:"ovamir-anjum",profilePath:"/team/ovamiranjum",name:"Dr. Ovamir Anjum",title:"Editor-in-Chief and Chair, Hashiya"},{cmsSlug:"tesneem-alkiek",profilePath:"/team/tesneem-alkiek",name:"Dr. Tesneem Alkiek",title:"Director of Editorial Strategy and Associate Chair, Hashiya"},{cmsSlug:"sh-tahir-wyatt",name:"Dr. Tahir Wyatt",title:"Director of Religious Scholarly Advancement & Integrity Assurance"},{cmsSlug:"tom-faccine",scholarKey:"tom-facchine",name:"Imam Tom Facchine",title:"Director of Community Impact and Narrative"},{cmsSlug:"sh-mohammad-elshinawy",profilePath:"/team/mohammad-elshinawy",name:"Sh. Mohammad Elshinawy",title:"Director of Content Strategy"},{cmsSlug:"yousef-wahb",profilePath:"/team/yousef-wahb",name:"Sh. Yousef Wahb",title:"Director of Scholar Recruitment and Academic Partnerships"}],o={"/about-us/our-commitment-to-scholarly-rigor":"2026-09-02T00:00:00-05:00"};

1var c=r(81984),d=r(51131),m=r(66284),h=r(77328),u=r.n(h),f=r(37067),p=r(56128),g=r(26581),x=r(37876);function b(e,t){var r=Object.keys(e);if(Object.getOwnPropertySymbols){var a=Object.getOwnPropertySymbols(e);t&&(a=a.filter(function(t){return Object.getOwnPropertyDescriptor(e,t).enumerable})),r.push.apply(r,a)}return r}function y(e){for(var t=1;t<arguments.length;t++){var r=null!=arguments[t]?arguments[t]:{};t%2?b(Object(r),!0).forEach(function(t){(0,m.A)(e,t,r[t])}):Object.getOwnPropertyDescriptors?Object.defineProperties(e,Object.getOwnPropertyDescriptors(r)):b(Object(r)).forEach(function(t){Object.defineProperty(e,t,Object.getOwnPropertyDescriptor(r,t))})}return e}let j=e=>y(y(y({"@type":"EducationalOccupationalCredential",name:e.name},e.url?{url:e.url}:{}),e.category?{credentialCategory:e.category}:{}),e.description?{description:e.description}:{}),v=()=>{let e=n.map(e=>{var t,r,a,i;let s=null==(t=e.profilePath)?void 0:t.replace("/team/",""),l=(0,f.F)(e.scholarKey)??(0,f.F)(e.cmsSlug)??(0,f.F)(s),n={"@type":"Person",name:e.name,jobTitle:e.title,worksFor:{"@id":g.Pk["@id"]}};return n["@id"]=`${g.Pk.url}/team/${e.cmsSlug}#person`,e.profilePath&&(n.url=`${g.Pk.url}${e.profilePath}`),null!=l&&null!=(r=l.sameAs)&&r.length&&(n.sameAs=l.sameAs),null!=l&&l.honorificPrefix&&(n.honorificPrefix=l.honorificPrefix),null!=l&&null!=(a=l.hasCredential)&&a.length&&(n.hasCredential=l.hasCredential.map(j)),null!=l&&null!=(i=l.alumniOf)&&i.length&&(n.alumniOf=l.alumniOf.map(e=>y({"@type":e.type||"Organization",name:e.name},e.url?{url:e.url}:{}))),n});if(!e.length)return(0,x.jsx)(x.Fragment,{});let t={"@context":g.WX,"@graph":[{"@type":"Organization","@id":g.Pk["@id"],member:e}]};return(0,x.jsx)(u(),{children:(0,x.jsx)("script",{type:"application/ld+json",dangerouslySetInnerHTML:{__html:(0,p.q)(t)}})})};var w=r(8333),N=r(69174),S=r(67579),O=r(86400);let E="https://yaqeeninstitute.org",k="/about-us/our-commitment-to-scholarly-rigor",P=`${E}${k}`,Y=[{title:"Home",href:"/"},{title:"Scholarly rigor",href:"/about-us/our-commitment-to-scholarly-rigor"}];var D=!0;let z=e=>{let{teamMembers:t}=e,r={title:"Our Commitment to Scholarly Rigor",description:"How Yaqeen research is reviewed, and what happens to it after publication. An editorial board and peer review committee of scholars, and a policy of updating or archiving published articles to correct errors, add references and reflect new work.",url:P,canonical:P,addOrganizationSchema:!0,breadcrumbs:Y.map(e=>({name:e.title,url:"/"===e.href?E:`${E}${e.href}`})),webPage:{dateModified:o[k],pageType:"AboutPage",mainEntityId:`${E}/#org`,mainEntityType:"Organization",mainEntityName:"Yaqeen Institute for Islamic Research",speakable:!0,speakableCssSelectors:d.R_,description:"Yaqeen Institute’s editorial board, peer review committee, and the policy under which published articles are updated or archived."}},i=(e=>{let{0:t,1:r}=(0,a.useState)(e?"loading":"idle");return(0,a.useEffect)(()=>{if(!e)return void r("idle");let t=document.querySelector(`script[src="${e}"]`);if(t)r(t.getAttribute("data-status"));else{(t=document.createElement("script")).src=e,t.async=!0,t.setAttribute("data-status","loading"),document.body.appendChild(t);let r=e=>{t.setAttribute("data-status","load"===e.type?"ready":"error")};t.addEventListener("load",r),t.addEventListener("error",r)}let a=e=>{r("load"===e.type?"ready":"error")};return t.addEventListener("load",a),t.addEventListener("error",a),()=>{t&&(t.removeEventListener("load",a),t.removeEventListener("error",a))}},[e]),t})("https://js.hsforms.net/forms/v2.js");return(0,a.useEffect)(()=>{let e=document.getElementsByClassName("hs-form-iframe")[0];"ready"===i&&window.hbspt&&!e&&window.hbspt.forms.create({portalId:"4713562",formId:"71171e8f-fa16-4855-91bd-852323f5f9bf",target:"#contactUsForm"})},[i]),(0,x.jsxs)(S.MainWebLayout,{metatag:r,children:[(0,x.jsx)(v,{}),(0,x.jsxs)(S.MainWebContentLayout,{className:"xl:mb-6 mb-10",children:[(0,x.jsx)(S.PageHeader,{pageTitle:r.title,breadcrumbs:Y,colorItems:[1]}),(0,x.jsx)("div",{className:"border-t border-grey-200 mt-4"}),(0,x.jsxs)("div",{className:"mt-8",children:[(0,x.jsx)(N.EY,{as:"p",fontFamily:"font-source-serif-pro",fontSize:"xl:text-lg text-base",color:"text-grey-800",lineHeight:"leading-relaxed",children:"Yaqeen Institute serves as a platform bringing together a variety of Muslim scholars, academics, and intellectuals discussing topics of central importance to the contemporary Muslim community. Our team consists of scholars who represent diverse institutions of traditional Islamic learning as well as intellectuals from various fields relevant to the challenges we address."}),(0,x.jsxs)("div",{id:"three-principles",className:"mt-6 scroll-mt-24",children:[(0,x.jsx)(N.EY,{as:"p",fontFamily:"font-source-serif-pro",fontSize:"xl:text-lg text-base",color:"text-grey-800",lineHeight:"leading-relaxed",children:"At Yaqeen Institute, we strive to maintain the following three principles in our commitment to scholarly rigor:"}),(0,x.jsx)("ol",{role:"list",className:"mt-6 mb-6 grid list-none gap-6 md:grid-cols-3",children:c.a.map((e,t)=>{let{term:r,gloss:a}=e;return(0,x.jsxs)("li",{className:"rounded-lg border border-slate-200 p-6",children:[(0,x.jsx)(N.EY,{as:"span",fontSize:"text-sm",weight:"font-bold",color:"text-carrot-500",letterSpacing:"tracking-widest",className:"block",children:`0${t+1}`}),(0,x.jsx)(N.EY,{as:"span",fontFamily:"font-source-serif-pro",fontSize:"xl:text-3xl text-2xl",weight:"font-semibold",color:"text-endeavour-500",lineHeight:"leading-tight",className:"mt-2 mb-3 block italic",children:r}),(0,x.jsx)(N.EY,{as:"p",fontFamily:"font-source-serif-pro",fontSize:"text-base",color:"text-grey-800",lineHeight:"leading-relaxed",children:a})]},r)})})]}),(0,x.jsx)("div",{id:"orthodoxy-and-difference",className:"mt-6 scroll-mt-24",children:(0,x.jsxs)(N.EY,{as:"p",fontFamily:"font-source-serif-pro",fontSize:"xl:text-lg text-base",color:"text-grey-800",lineHeight:"leading-relaxed",children:["Yaqeen Institute aims to defend and promote Islamic orthodoxy and provide insight into the views that fall within the scope of valid differences of opinion. (",(0,x.jsx)(N.qh,{href:"https://yaqeeninstitute.org/collections/collections-the-straight-path-finding-guidance-in-an-age-of-confusion/#.XfPHwNZKhE4",className:"url",children:"See more"}),")"]})}),(0,x.jsxs)("div",{id:"revising-and-archiving",className:"mt-6 scroll-mt-24",children:[(0,x.jsx)(N.EY,{as:"p",fontFamily:"font-source-serif-pro",fontSize:"xl:text-lg text-base",color:"text-grey-800",lineHeight:"leading-relaxed",children:"Maintaining scholarly rigor is an indispensable part of this work. In the pursuit of truth, one of the most critical elements is to revise and improve c

1ontent."}),(0,x.jsx)(N.EY,{as:"p",fontFamily:"font-source-serif-pro",fontSize:"xl:text-lg text-base",color:"text-grey-800",lineHeight:"leading-relaxed",className:"mt-6",children:"Consequently, articles on our website will be updated or archived from time-to-time in order to feature new content, add references, correct errors, and offer further explanations when needed. In doing this, we can provide readers with the most up-to-date and rigorous scholarship on a particular topic, vetted by a panel of scholars and researchers."})]}),(0,x.jsxs)("div",{className:"mt-12 flex flex-col gap-8 border-y border-grey-200 py-6 md:flex-row md:gap-16",children:[(0,x.jsxs)("div",{className:"shrink-0",children:[(0,x.jsx)(N.EY,{as:"span",fontSize:"text-xs",weight:"font-bold",color:"text-grey-700",letterSpacing:"tracking-widest",className:"block uppercase",children:"Peer-reviewed papers"}),(0,x.jsxs)(N.qh,{href:"/read/papers",className:"group mt-1 block",children:[(0,x.jsx)(N.EY,{as:"span",fontSize:"text-3xl",weight:"font-extrabold",color:"text-endeavour-500",letterSpacing:"tracking-tight-2",className:"block",children:277}),(0,x.jsx)(N.EY,{fontSize:"text-sm",weight:"font-bold",letterSpacing:"tracking-tight-1",className:"group-hover:underline",children:"Read the library"})]})]}),(0,x.jsxs)("div",{className:"md:max-w-[560px] md:flex-1",children:[(0,x.jsx)(N.EY,{as:"span",fontSize:"text-xs",weight:"font-bold",color:"text-grey-700",letterSpacing:"tracking-widest",className:"block uppercase",children:"The public record"}),(0,x.jsx)("div",{className:"mt-2 divide-y divide-grey-200 border-y border-grey-200",children:[{href:"/papers/update",label:"See recently updated papers"},{href:"/papers/archive",label:"See archived papers"}].map(e=>{let{href:t,label:r}=e;return(0,x.jsxs)(N.qh,{href:t,className:"group flex items-center justify-between py-3",children:[(0,x.jsx)(N.EY,{fontSize:"text-sm",weight:"font-bold",letterSpacing:"tracking-tight-1",className:"group-hover:underline",children:r}),(0,x.jsx)(l.g,{icon:"chevron-right",size:"sm",className:"text-carrot-500"})]},t)})})]})]})]}),(0,x.jsx)("div",{className:"mt-12",children:(0,x.jsx)(S.SubscribeCTA,{})})]}),(0,x.jsx)("div",{id:"senior-editorial-team",className:"bg-grey-0 scroll-mt-24",children:(0,x.jsx)(S.MainWebContentLayout,{className:"xl:py-20 py-10",children:(0,x.jsxs)("div",{className:"flex xl:flex-row flex-col xl:space-x-20",children:[(0,x.jsxs)("div",{className:"mb-5 xl:w-96",children:[(0,x.jsx)("div",{className:"mb-4",children:(0,x.jsx)(N.DZ,{color:"text-endeavour-500",weight:"font-extrabold",fontSize:"text-3xl",lineHeight:"xl:leading-8 leading-9",children:"Meet Our Senior Editorial Team Members"})}),(0,x.jsx)("div",{className:"mb-4",children:(0,x.jsx)(N.EY,{as:"p",fontFamily:"font-source-serif-pro",lineHeight:"leading-relaxed",fontSize:"text-sm",color:"text-grey-700",children:"Yaqeen’s editorial team brings together scholars with traditional and academic training. Reviewers are assigned to each paper according to their expertise."})}),(0,x.jsx)("div",{className:"mb-4",children:(0,x.jsx)(N.qh,{href:"/team",children:(0,x.jsxs)("div",{className:"flex items-center",children:[(0,x.jsx)("div",{className:"mr-3",children:(0,x.jsx)(N.EY,{weight:"font-bold",letterSpacing:"tracking-tight-1",children:"Meet the Yaqeen team"})}),(0,x.jsx)(l.g,{icon:"chevron-right",size:"sm",className:"text-carrot-500"})]})})})]}),(0,x.jsx)("div",{className:"grid xl:grid-cols-2 xl:gap-y-10 gap-y-8 xl:gap-x-20 xl:w-192",children:n.map(e=>{let r=t.find(t=>t.slug===e.cmsSlug),a=(0,x.jsx)("div",{className:"h-[84px] w-[84px] shrink-0 overflow-hidden rounded-full bg-grey-200",children:null!=r&&r.thumbnail?(0,x.jsx)(s(),{src:(0,O.AE)(r.thumbnail),alt:`${e.name} profile photo`,loader:O.R2,height:84,width:84,className:"h-full w-full rounded-full object-cover"}):null}),i=(0,x.jsx)(N.DZ,{level:3,weight:"font-bold",letterSpacing:"tracking-tight-1",children:e.name});return(0,x.jsx)("div",{className:"author-desktop",children:(0,x.jsxs)("div",{className:"flex items-center",children:[e.profilePath?(0,x.jsx)(N.qh,{href:e.profilePath,children:a}):a,(0,x.jsxs)("div",{className:"author-info w-full pl-6",children:[e.profilePath?(0,x.jsx)(N.qh,{href:e.profilePath,children:i}):i,(0,x.jsx)(N.EY,{as:"p",fontFamily:"font-source-serif-pro",fontSize:"text-xs",color:"text-grey-800",className:"italic",children:e.title})]})]})},e.name)})})]})})}),(0,x.jsx)(S.MainWebContentLayout,{id:"editorial-feedback",className:"xl:py-20 py-10 scroll-mt-24",children:(0,x.jsxs)("div",{className:"flex xl:flex-row flex-col xl:space-x-20",children:[(0,x.jsxs)("div",{className:"xl:mb-0 mb-6 xl:w-96",children:[(0,x.jsx)("div",{className:"mb-4",children:(0,x.jsx)(N.DZ,{

1color:"text-endeavour-500",weight:"font-extrabold",fontSize:"text-3xl",lineHeight:"xl:leading-8 leading-9",children:"Editorial Feedback Form"})}),(0,x.jsxs)("div",{className:"mb-4",children:[(0,x.jsx)(N.EY,{as:"p",fontFamily:"font-source-serif-pro",lineHeight:"leading-relaxed",fontSize:"text-sm",color:"text-grey-700",children:"Contributors to Yaqeen Institute for Islamic Research welcome feedback and commit to continuously improving content with updated information, greater clarity, and further scholarly resources. To facilitate this process, share your comments directly with the editorial team and authors of our papers."}),(0,x.jsx)("br",{}),(0,x.jsx)(N.EY,{as:"p",fontFamily:"font-source-serif-pro",lineHeight:"leading-relaxed",fontSize:"text-sm",color:"text-grey-700",children:"Once received, your comments and suggestions will be reviewed and the original paper will be assigned to a second set of scholars to determine if and to what degree changes are warranted."})]})]}),(0,x.jsx)("div",{className:"xl:w-192",children:(0,x.jsx)("div",{id:"contactUsForm",className:"w-full"})})]})}),(0,x.jsx)(S.MainWebContentLayout,{className:"pb-16",children:(0,x.jsx)(w.A,{currentPath:"/about-us/our-commitment-to-scholarly-rigor"})})]})}}},e=>{e.O(0,[5123,1510,2697,4740,1502,4587,2682,6241,5542,3822,5807,3971,636,6593,8792],()=>e(e.s=86094)),_N_E=e.O()}]);