https://uj-prioritization-dashboard.netlify.app/feedback_summary.js

1window.PAPER_FEEDBACK_SUMMARY={"papers":{"url:papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5184250":{"n":1,"human_mean":50.0,"human_unweighted_mean":50.0,"human_weight":1.0,"team_n":1,"public_n":0,"quick_n":1,"detailed_n":0,"detailed_discussion_n":0,"updated_at":"2026-07-30T23:16:47.387Z","public_discussions":[{"display_name":"David Reinstein","discussion":"It's hard for me to rate this without seeing some more details about the nature of the experiment/trial. Clearly an important issue in terms of global priorities, animal welfare, but here, the potential impact really depends on the scale and credibility of the experiment and how natural it was and how consequential the decisions were being made","rating":50.0,"rating_kind":"Quick","created_date":"2026-07-30"}]},"url:arxiv.org/abs/2603.21699v1":{"n":3,"human_mean":33.33,"human_unweighted_mean":31.67,"human_weight":6.0,"team_n":1,"public_n":2,"quick_n":2,"detailed_n":1,"detailed_discussion_n":1,"updated_at":"2026-08-25T15:49:14.871Z","public_discussions":[{"display_name":"David Reinstein","discussion":"Seems inherently a rich country problem and not existential/GCR. Interesting, and I expect there's a lot of total social value in worker-employer matching. However, my initial take (and this is shallow) is that this individual algorithm is unlikely to have a huge impact on the gains from better matching, given in comparison to existing algorithms. It seems somewhat more actionable than other work in this area, but still it seems to be a bit more on the theoretical building block side than we would usually focus on. I also anticipate so many changes in the labor market driven by AI in the next few years that this research might no longer be highly relevant","rating":35.0,"rating_kind":"Detailed","created_date":"2026-08-24"}]},"url:nber.org/papers/w34978":{"n":1,"human_mean":50.0,"human_unweighted_mean":50.0,"human_weight":1.0,"team_n":1,"public_n":0,"quick_n":1,"detailed_n":0,"detailed_discussion_n":0,"updated_at":"2026-07-30T23:07:50.237Z","public_discussions":[{"display_name":"David Reinstein","discussion":"I haven't read the paper or gone further than the description above . Without knowing what methods are used here, it's hard for me to know whether it's something that is likely to have real meaning and something that people are likely to use and adopt. It does seem to be one of the top issues at stake in trying to strike a climate deal. At least this is the discussion that comes up a lot and seems to potentially bottleneck any deal, but I'm not sure how much having a theoretical method for allocating it will help that question. \n\nI have some connection with Galena, if I recall, so that could help secure author engagement. \n\n

1I'm not immediately aware that any funders are considering or using this, but it's quite possible.","rating":50.0,"rating_kind":"Quick","created_date":"2026-07-30"}]},"url:nber.org/papers/w35451":{"n":3,"human_mean":76.67,"human_unweighted_mean":76.67,"human_weight":3.0,"team_n":0,"public_n":3,"quick_n":3,"detailed_n":0,"detailed_discussion_n":0,"updated_at":"2026-08-31T18:16:27.025Z"},"url:nber.org/papers/w35478":{"n":1,"human_mean":90.0,"human_unweighted_mean":90.0,"human_weight":1.0,"team_n":0,"public_n":1,"quick_n":1,"detailed_n":0,"detailed_discussion_n":0,"updated_at":"2026-08-24T20:32:04.984Z"},"url:papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5255360":{"n":1,"human_mean":70.0,"human_unweighted_mean":70.0,"human_weight":1.0,"team_n":0,"public_n":1,"quick_n":1,"detailed_n":0,"detailed_discussion_n":0,"updated_at":"2026-08-25T22:20:33.083Z"},"url:thedocs.worldbank.org/en/doc/07f7fe676b8331172af31de2c3fc11e1-0050062026/original/cross-country-labor-demand-in-the-age-of-genai-0727.pdf":{"n":1,"human_mean":70.0,"human_unweighted_mean":70.0,"human_weight":1.0,"team_n":0,"public_n":1,"quick_n":1,"detailed_n":0,"detailed_discussion_n":0,"updated_at":"2026-08-25T22:20:21.301Z"},"url:thedocs.worldbank.org/en/doc/ae79099bd924fb298c1922e640f5ac4d-0050062026/original/artificial-intelligence-interventions.pdf":{"n":1,"human_mean":90.0,"human_unweighted_mean":90.0,"human_weight":1.0,"team_n":0,"public_n":1,"quick_n":1,"detailed_n":0,"detailed_discussion_n":0,"updated_at":"2026-08-25T22:16:06.347Z"},"url:papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4867295":{"n":1,"human_mean":50.0,"human_unweighted_mean":50.0,"human_weight":1.0,"team_n":0,"public_n":1,"quick_n":1,"detailed_n":0,"detailed_discussion_n":0,"updated_at":"2026-08-25T22:15:07.885Z"},"url:nber.org/papers/w35334":{"n":1,"human_mean":50.0,"human_unweighted_mean":50.0,"human_weight":1.0,"team_n":0,"public_n":1,"quick_n":1,"detailed_n":0,"detailed_discussion_n":0,"updated_at":"2026-08-25T22:14:56.314Z"},"url:arxiv.org/abs/2605.17086v1":{"n":1,"human_mean":90.0,"human_unweighted_mean":90.0,"human_weight":1.0,"team_n":0,"public_n":1,"quick_n":1,"detailed_n":0,"detailed_discussion_n":0,"updated_at":"2026-08-25T22:51:33.011Z"},"url:doi.org/10.3386/w34444":{"n":1,"human_mean":50.0,"human_unweighted_mean":50.0,"human_weight":1.0,"team_n":0,"public_n":1,"quick_n":1,"detailed_n":0,"detailed_discussion_n":0,"updated_at":"2026-08-31T17:41:29.153Z"},"url:thedocs.worldbank.org/en/doc/d531dfdd855a57988e33c464d780cae1-0050062026/original/ai-adoption-in-developing-countries.pdf":{"n":1,"human_mean":70.0,"human_unweighted_mean":70.0,"human_weight":1.0,"team_n":0,"public_n":1,"quick_n":1,"detailed_n":0,"detailed_discussion_n":0,"updated_at":"2026-08-31T18:52:51.495Z"}},"stats":{"min_public_group_n":3,"metrics":{"overall":{"label":"Overall priority rating","scale_max":100,"summary":{"n":17,"rated_papers":13,"mean":62.06,"median":70.0,"q1":50.0,"q3":70.0,"min":30.0,"max":90.0,"histogram":[{"label":"0–9","count":0},{"label":"10–19","count":0},{"label":"20–29","count":0},{"label":"30–39","count":3},{"label":"40–49","count":0},{"label":"50–59","count":5},{"label":"60–69","count":0},{"label":"70–79","count":5},{"label":"80–89","count":0},{"label":"90–100","count":4}]},"breakdowns":{"cause_area":{"AI, technology & governance":{"n":7,"rated_papers":5,"mean":72.86,"median":70.0,"q1":70.0,"q3":80.0,"min":50.0,"max":90.0,"histogram":[{"label":"0–9","count":0},{"label":"10–19","count":0},{"label":"20–29","count":0},{"label":"30–39","count":0},{"label":"40–49","count":0},{"label":"50–59","count":1},{"label":"60–69","count":0},{"label":"70–79","count":4},{"label":"80–89","count":0},{"label":"90–100","count":2}]},"Animal welfare & food systems":{"n":3,"rated_papers":3,"mean":56.67,"median":50.0,"q1":50.0,"q3":60.0,"min":50.0,"max":70.0,"histogram":[{"label":"0–9","count":0},{"label":"10–19","count":0},{"label":"20–29","count":0},{"label":"30–39","count":0},{"label":"40–49","count":0},{"label":"50–59","count":2},{"label":"60–69","count":0},{"label":"70–79","count":1},{"label":"80–89","count":0},{"label":"90–100","count":0}]},"Environment & climate":{"n":1,"rated_papers":1,"suppressed":true},"Global health, development & well-being":{"n":2,"rated_papers":2,"suppressed":true},"Other: economics & policy":{"n":4,"rated_papers":2,"mean":36.25,"median":32.5,"q1":30.0,"q3":38.75,"min":30.0,"max":50.0,"histogram":[{"label":"0–9","count":0},{"label":"10–19","count":0},{"label":"20–29","count":0},{"label":"30–39","count":3},{"label":"40–49","count":0},{"label":"50–59","count":1},{"label":"60–69","count":0},{"label":"70–79","count":0},{"label":"80–89","count":0},{"label":"90–100","count":0}]}},"rater_group":{"Public":{"n":14,"rated_papers":11,"mean":65.71,"median":70.0,"q1":50.0,"q3":85.0,"min":30.0,"max":90.0,"histogram":[{"label":"0–9","count":0},{"label":"10–19","count":0},{"label":"20–29","count":0},{"label":"30–39","count":2},{"label":"40–49","count":0},{"label":"50–59","count":3},{"label":"60–69","count":0},{"label":"70–79","count":5},{"label":"80–89","count":0},{"label":"90–100","count":4}

1]},"Team":{"n":3,"rated_papers":3,"mean":45.0,"median":50.0,"q1":42.5,"q3":50.0,"min":35.0,"max":50.0,"histogram":[{"label":"0–9","count":0},{"label":"10–19","count":0},{"label":"20–29","count":0},{"label":"30–39","count":1},{"label":"40–49","count":0},{"label":"50–59","count":2},{"label":"60–69","count":0},{"label":"70–79","count":0},{"label":"80–89","count":0},{"label":"90–100","count":0}]}},"rating_kind":{"Detailed":{"n":1,"rated_papers":1,"suppressed":true},"Quick":{"n":16,"rated_papers":13,"mean":63.75,"median":70.0,"q1":50.0,"q3":75.0,"min":30.0,"max":90.0,"histogram":[{"label":"0–9","count":0},{"label":"10–19","count":0},{"label":"20–29","count":0},{"label":"30–39","count":2},{"label":"40–49","count":0},{"label":"50–59","count":5},{"label":"60–69","count":0},{"label":"70–79","count":5},{"label":"80–89","count":0},{"label":"90–100","count":4}]}}}},"decision_relevance":{"label":"Potential decision relevance","scale_max":10,"summary":{"n":0,"rated_papers":0,"suppressed":true},"breakdowns":{"cause_area":{},"rater_group":{},"rating_kind":{}}},"evaluability":{"label":"Evaluability / methods","scale_max":10,"summary":{"n":0,"rated_papers":0,"suppressed":true},"breakdowns":{"cause_area":{},"rater_group":{},"rating_kind":{}}},"timing":{"label":"Timing value","scale_max":10,"summary":{"n":0,"rated_papers":0,"suppressed":true},"breakdowns":{"cause_area":{},"rater_group":{},"rating_kind":{}}},"scrutiny_gap":{"label":"Remaining scrutiny gap","scale_max":10,"summary":{"n":0,"rated_papers":0,"suppressed":true},"breakdowns":{"cause_area":{},"rater_group":{},"rating_kind":{}}},"influence":{"label":"Likely influence","scale_max":10,"summary":{"n":0,"rated_papers":0,"suppressed":true},"breakdowns":{"cause_area":{},"rater_group":{},"rating_kind":{}}},"prominence":{"label":"Prominence / attention","scale_max":10,"summary":{"n":0,"rated_papers":0,"suppressed":true},"breakdowns":{"cause_area":{},"rater_group":{},"rating_kind":{}}}}},"meta":{"generated_at":"2026-10-01T14:51:42+00:00","included_ratings":17,"rated_papers":13,"public_discussions":3,"public_ratings":0,"unmatched_submissions":0,"invalid_submissions":0,"vote_mapping":{"1":10,"2":30,"3":50,"4":70,"5":90},"synthesis_prior_strength":3,"rating_weights":{"quick":1,"full_without_detailed_discussion":2,"public_full_with_detailed_discussion":3,"team_full_with_detailed_discussion":4},"detailed_discussion_rule":"At least 120 characters or 20 words.","synthesis_method":"AI score is the prior mean with a weight of three quick-rating equivalents; human ratings use the published ad-hoc evidence/detail weights.","privacy":"Only anonymous counts and numeric aggregates from verified or legacy accepted submissions are public; subgroup statistics with fewer than 3 ratings are suppressed. Discussion text appears only after explicit public-sharing consent; names appear only after explicit named-attribution consent, for a discussion or (from notice 2026-09-30) a numeric rating. When named ratings are listed, the mean of the remaining anonymous ratings is shown only for 3 or more. Emails, rating keys, and submission ids are excluded."}}

1;